Labor Update: Judge delivers wage uncertainty to agriculture once again
An H-2A wage ruling leaves agricultural employers facing uncertainty over labor costs and potential back pay. Examine the decision and assess its implications.
Judge Kirk Sherriff’s Aug. 26 ruling against the Department of Labor’s Interim Final Rule on H-2A wages is more than a dispute over administrative procedure. It shows what happens when courts mistake broad agricultural statistics for the economic reality facing labor-intensive growers.
The court found that major elements of the rule, including its two-tier wage structure, housing adjustment and treatment of workers performing multiple jobs were arbitrary and capricious. It also concluded that the Trump administration had not shown the emergency conditions needed to bypass the public comment process, pointing to economic indicators suggesting agriculture was performing relatively well. That assessment may make sense from 30,000 feet. It makes far less sense from the seat of a tractor.
The fundamental flaw is treating agriculture as a single industry with a single economic reality. It is not. Much of the improvement in aggregate farm income came from sectors that rely little or not at all on H-2A labor. Fruit, vegetable, nursery and other labor-intensive producers faced rising labor costs, shrinking margins, higher borrowing costs, foreign competition and persistent workforce shortages — conditions many growers would call a crisis. And they cannot postpone production until conditions improve. Crops must be planted and harvested, and much of that work still requires people.
The rule sought to address that reality with a wage methodology designed to better reflect labor markets. Industry estimates suggest it provides roughly $17.3 billion in wage relief. For many farms, that is not a windfall. It is the difference between maintaining production and reducing acreage, between investing and delaying, between competing and losing ground to foreign producers.
The court concluded these conditions did not justify extraordinary action. Growers living through them may reach a very different conclusion. And the industry is now in an even more precarious position than where it started.
The court did not vacate the rule. Current wage rates remain in place while the Department of Labor develops a replacement. But on Sept. 2, the Department warned employers that they could eventually owe back pay to H-2A workers and U.S. workers in corresponding employment if new rates exceed what they pay today. Nothing is owed yet, and the court has not resolved the question, but the potential liability grows with every paycheck, and no employer knows how large it may become. The Department told the court it needs nine to 12 months to craft a replacement. The United Farm Workers want a new interim methodology within weeks, or the rule struck down altogether. The judge found the Department’s new timeline too long, but what comes next remains a question.
Employers are once again left guessing what labor costs will be, and this time whether they will apply retroactively. Planning and investment become harder, and the pressures that prompted the rule have not disappeared because a court rejected the government’s response. That is the lesson Congress should take from this episode.
For decades, agricultural labor policy has been shaped by regulations, lawsuits and administrative reversals. One administration issues a rule. Another revises it. Courts intervene. Farmers are left operating under a system where the rules can change overnight. The latest ruling did not create that problem. It exposed it.
The only lasting solution is legislation. The Securing Agriculture’s Workforce Act, introduced by House Agriculture Committee chair Glenn “GT” Thompson, would write an H-2A wage standard into law and prevent wages from changing during the life of a contract. It would move agricultural labor policy out of the cycle of regulatory whiplash and establish a durable framework for the growers, workers and consumers who depend on it.
The debate over the Interim Final Rule was never really about administrative law. It was about whether Washington understands the economic realities facing labor-intensive agriculture. Too often, it does not. And until Congress acts, farmers will keep paying the price for that misunderstanding.
Written by John Hollay, president and CEO of National Council of Agricultural Employers.